Denman Island Housing Project (Phase 2) – Engagement on Key Themes
The Denman Housing Review Project was initiated to respond to the growing need for diverse and affordable housing options on Denman Island. As we head closer toward drafting bylaws to support this need the Denman LTC is inviting the Denman Community to learn about and comment on key themes that have emerged through the process. Your input will help shape housing policies that reflect Denman’s values and needs.
Each theme below includes background information and potential policy options. The accompanying survey asks for your thoughts on each one.
Cluster Housing
Attachment 3- Denman Housing Engagement Info: CLUSTER housing
Community-Scaled
Living
Units
Sited
Together for
Ecological and Economic
Resilience
What is Cluster Housing?
Cluster housing groups several small homes, attached or detached, on one lot without subdividing the land. This reduces development footprint and improves space and infrastructure efficiency.
Rezoning may require housing agreements and limits on individual or total floor area.
Are Cluster Homes Allowed on Denman?
Denman’s current Official Community Plan (OCP) supports rezoning for affordable, multi-unit housing. Including “cluster housing” in the OCP could make the process clearer and faster by eliminating the need for OCP amendments and providing specific guidelines or criteria.
Why Consider Cluster Housing?
Attainable Housing Potential – Facilitates land sharing through co-operative ownership arrangement.
Land Sharing Tradition– Reflects Denman’s history of communal living and aligns with community support.
Smaller Footprint-Clustering homes and infrastructure like wells and septic systems reduces environmental and archaeological impacts.
More Affordable Density: Cluster zoning allows increased density without subdivision, making housing potentially more affordable by sharing land and infrastructure.
How Could Cluster Housing Be Introduced?
Option 1: Rezoning Applications
- Update OCP policies to allow “cluster housing”.
- Set clear criteria for water, septic, site layout, total floor area, road access, and long-term affordability through housing agreements.
Option 2: Pre-Zoning by LTC
- LTC could identify and pre-zone specific lots for cluster housing.
- Larger lots could be split-zoned for cluster housing on part of the property, based on suitability (like septic, driveways, heritage protection).
Key Considerations for Suitable Land
Cluster housing zoning:
- Cannot be applied to ALR lands, protected areas, or parkland.
- Should avoid shorelines, sensitive archaeological/ecological areas, riparian areas, steep slopes and freshwater recharge areas.
- Mapping shows suitable locations for cluster housing are limited due to these restrictions.
Density Bank
What is the Density Bank?
The Density Bank was established in 2008 in the Official Community Plan (OCP) to manage residential development by capping total densities and encouraging land conservation through the transfer of densities from protected lands into the bank.
The density bank has proven challenging to use and is disconnected from broader planning efforts, lacks clear guidance on where density should go, and is poorly understood.
How the Density Bank is Structured:
Island-Wide Density Cap:
In 2010, Denman’s total residential capacity was capped at 994 units:
-826 already zoned
-128 potential via subdivision
Rezoning for additional units
– only allowed for affordable/special needs housing and accessory dwelling units (through TUP)
– housing agreement required for affordable/special needs housing
– only a 5% increase above 994 units (49 units in 2010) (there are only 7 left)
Density Bank Permissions
– In Appendix D of OCP
– units can be accessed through rezoning
– there are 7 left (but this is inaccurate considering farm plan density)
– more can be added if density is removed from other places
– density transfer when land is donated for conservation
– removal of subdivision potential
– LTC-initiated zoning changes that result in unused residential densities
dwelling unit, affordable housing means a deed restricted and/or rent controlled dwelling unit that is secured by a housing agreement, and is available to persons with a low income as defined by housing agreement for the dwelling unit; (Denman LUB)
secondary dwelling unit means a dwelling unit, which may be a moveable housing unit, that is accessory to a permitted principal dwelling unit and which is limited in floor area (Denman LUB . Note: Staff are recommending these units be referred to as accessory dwelling units to provide consistency with provincial and federal definitions. “Secondary dwelling unit” typically refers to a secondary suite that is within a primary residence)
Exploring Options for the Denman Island Density Bank
Two primary options are under consideration:
- Replace the Density Bank with stronger OCP policies and zoning regulations that clearly guide where and how growth occurs.
- Improve the Density Bank by refining its processes, aligning it with local housing needs, and simplifying administration.
Comparison of Options for the Denman Island Density Bank
Category | Current Density Bank | Option 1: Rethink Density -Replace with Clear Density Limiting Policies | Option 2: Rethink Density – -Clear Density Limiting Policies/Improve the Density Bank |
Purpose | To limit density to number in bank | To limit density and location of future growth (rethinking density) | |
Banked Density | 7 currently (not reflective of reality) | No Density bank growth managed through focussed policy and regulatory framework (clear criteria) | Add more to bank based on specific criteria. |
How densities is used | For affordable housing and ADUs (through TUP) | Only allow rezoning for additional density for affordable/ attainable housing (to be defined).
Allow ADUs in suitable areas (eg. limited impact to ecology/Indigenous cultural history) |
|
How Density is added | Rezoning tied to density transfer (removing potential units or subdivision potential ) | No Density bank – Existing density is moved from subdivision potential that currently existing in less suitable places | Same as current |
Housing Targets | Sets a cap on affordable housing/ADUs at 5% | An aspirational target could be set (eg. 30% of all new housing built by 2050 is affordable/attainable) | Would set a cap as opposed to an aspirational target |
Subdivision Control | None – existing subdivision potential can be realized | Proactively remove subdivision potential completely or in area with high ecological, cultural impacts, climate risks etc. Move density to suitable areas to facilitate more affordable/attainable housing (ADUs/cluster housing) | Same as 1, but densities removed are added to the Bank. |
Accessory Dwellings Units | Included in bank | Not Applicable | Remove Policy 12 reference so secondary dwellings (ADUs) no longer adds to density. ADUs permitted in suitable areas. |
Conservation linkage | Conservation encouraged through density transfer | Focusing growth in suitable areas to encourage conservation. Density transfer still supported. |
Lot Coverage and Floor Area Restrictions
What Are Lot Coverage and Floor Area?
Lot Coverage
Lot coverage refers to the percentage of a lot’s total area that is covered by buildings, measured by the building footprints (only the area they take up on the ground).
Floor Area
Floor area refers to the total usable interior space of a building across all levels. It provides a more direct measure of the actual size of a house or structure.
What Lot Coverage and Floor Area Controls Currently Exist?
Current Policy on Denman Island:
- 25% maximum lot coverage for residential lots
What options exist for controlling Lot Coverage and Floor Area?
Lot Coverage Restriction
Lot coverage limits how much of a lot can be covered by buildings and structures. It regulates only the building footprint. This tool is useful for protecting open space, limiting impervious surfaces, and maintaining Denman Island’s natural character.
Option based on review of lot coverage across the Islands Trust Area:
Lot Size | Lot Coverage | Max Footprint (m2) | Approx. House Size (GFA, 2 Storeys) |
< 0.6 ha (1.5 acres) | 15% | 900 m²
|
1,800 m² (19, 375ft2) |
1.2 ha (3acres) | 10% | 1200 m² | 2400m² (25,833ft2) |
5 ha (12.35 acres) | 5% | 2500 m² | 5,000 m² (53,820 ft²) |
10ha (24.70 acres) | 5% | 5000 m²
|
10,000m² (107,639ft2) |
10 ha + | 5% |
Floor Area Restriction
Floor area limits the total interior space of a building across all floors. It directly controls the overall size of a building.
Option:
- Establish a fixed maximum floor area for the principal dwelling on all lots (e.g. 250m²/2,690 ft²)
- Note: A 250 m² home on a 0.5 acre lot uses ~6% coverage.
- Variances may be granted on a case-by-case basis, subject to review and approval by the LTC.
Alternative:
- Set grouped maximum floor areas by zoning (e.g., R1 zones allow smaller maximums than R2).
- Set grouped maximum floor areas by property size (e.g., 0–5 acres = 2,000 ft², 5–10 acres = 4,000 ft², etc.).
Recommended Approach
Staff recommends adopting a combined approach that limits both lot coverage and gross floor area, with a maximum GFA of 250 m² for principal dwellings. This strategy ensures that buildings remain appropriately sized in both footprint and overall interior space. Limiting lot coverage helps protect open space, maintain the natural character of the area, and control impervious surfaces that impact drainage and ecology. Meanwhile, a fixed GFA cap discourages oversized homes, promotes modest and attainable housing.
Secondary Dwelling Units
What is a secondary dwelling unit?
A secondary dwelling unit is a small, self-contained home with its own kitchen, bathroom, and sleeping area, located on the same property as the main house. These can include:
- Secondary suites – units inside the main house (e.g., basement or in-law suites)
- Accessory Dwelling Unit (ADU)– stand-alone units like garden suites, tiny homes on wheels, cob houses, or modular homes
- Accessory residential unit (ARU) – either a detached building or within a portion of a building, on the same lot as a non-residential principal use
What’s currently allowed on Denman Island?
- Secondary suites are permitted in the R2 (Rural Residential), A (Agriculture), F (Forestry), and RE (Resource) zones.
- Detached secondary dwellings are allowed in the R2, RE and F zones with a Temporary Use Permit (TUP) and in the A zone outright.
Options for Supporting Secondary Dwelling Units:
- Expand secondary suite permission
- This would be primarily in R1 (smaller lot residential)
- Not compatible in conservation, water zones and R4 (Denman Green)
- Expand accessory residential unit permission
-
- Residential use is currently permitted in the commercial and light industrial zones not in community zones
- The LTC has approved draft language to permit residential in community zones
- Allow an ADU or a secondary suites on eligible lots
-
- Currently, only secondary suites are allowed as a principal use. This option would allow property owners to choose either type.
- Allow secondary suites and ADU on eligible lots
-
- Both a secondary suite and ADU could be permitted with conditions
- Allow more than one ADU with a maximum combined floor area for all units in suitable areas (Flexible housing)
-
- Maximum combined floor area and number of units would correspond with the size of lot for example:
Lot Size | Number of units | Maximum Combined floor area |
< 0.6 ha (1.5 acres) | 3 | 2500ft2 |
0.6 ha (1.5 acres – 1.2 ha (3acres) | 5 | 3,500ft2 |
1.2 ha (3 acres) – 5 ha (12.35 acres) | 6 | 4,750 ft2 |
5ha (12.35 acres) – 10ha (24.70 acres) | 7 | 7000 ft2 |
Introducing some or all of the options will increase housing options over the long-term and potentially enable a number of currently non conforming secondary dwelling units into legal conformity.
Each option above could be supported by the following conditions:
- Removal of the TUP requirement for accessory dwelling units
-
- This could permit secondary dwelling units outright where ADUs are permitted
- Allow secondary suites and ADUs in suitable areas only
-
- Use mapping to guide where these homes can go, avoiding sensitive areas like shorelines, steep slopes, wetlands, and areas of archeological and environmental significance (eg. not with in 200 metres from the natural boundary of the sea).
- Preliminary mapping suggests limited areas are suitable for additional density and intensity of land use.
- Zoning Requirements
-
- Conditions could include size limits, location close to the main house, and water collection requirements to reduce environmental impact.
Give us your feedback!
Contact Trustees:
Sam Borthwick
Denman Island Trustee
E: Trustee Borthwick
T: 1-250-845-9477
David Graham
Denman Island Trustee
E: Trustee Graham
T: 1-250-218-6871
Updates
Subscribe for updates to receive the latest information directly from Islands Trust.